RCEM statement on competency-based assessment

06.10.26

The Royal College of Emergency Medicine (RCEM) has recently received enquiries regarding the assessment and verification of competencies outside recognised UK postgraduate training programmes.

Competency-based medical education is founded on the principle that doctors demonstrate the knowledge, skills and professional behaviours required for safe independent clinical practice. Assessment is therefore based upon professional judgement arising from direct observation of clinical practice over time, supported by multiple complementary sources of evidence, including workplace-based assessments, multisource feedback, reflective practice, Educational Supervisor reports, ESLEs and appraisal.

Completion of workplace-based assessments does not, in itself, demonstrate competence. Competence is established through professional judgement based on repeated direct observation of clinical practice, triangulation of multiple sources of evidence and sufficient longitudinal knowledge of the applicant’s performance. Individual assessments should not be viewed in isolation but interpreted within the wider context of a doctor’s overall clinical practice and professional development.

Doctors who undertake workplace-based assessments, Educational Supervisor reports, ESLEs or other forms of competency verification have a professional responsibility under the General Medical Council’s Good Medical Practice to ensure that the judgements they make are honest, objective, evidence-based and capable of being justified. Assessors should therefore only verify competencies where they have sufficient direct knowledge of the doctor’s clinical practice and are satisfied that the assessment represents a fair, accurate and defensible professional judgement.

RCEM reviewers will expect competency assessments submitted in support of Portfolio Pathway applications to have been undertaken by clinicians who have directly supervised the applicant in routine clinical practice and have sufficient longitudinal knowledge of their performance to make a defensible professional judgement where this is appropriate to the competency being assessed. Whilst recognising that some competencies are appropriately assessed in simulation, on accredited courses or through other structured educational activities, competencies relating to routine clinical practice should normally be evidenced through direct workplace observation and longitudinal supervision. Assessments or competency verification undertaken remotely, or by clinicians without appropriate direct workplace supervision of the applicant, will not ordinarily be regarded as sufficient evidence by RCEM reviewers when advising the GMC on Portfolio Pathway applications for specialist registration that routine clinical curriculum competencies have been achieved.

Following discussions with the General Medical Council, RCEM intends to update the Emergency Medicine Specialty Specific Guidance to make these principles more explicit and to provide greater clarity for applicants, assessors and reviewers. In the interim, RCEM is publishing this statement to clarify the standards that the College expects when competency evidence is submitted in support of Portfolio Pathway applications for specialist registration.

RCEM fully supports high-quality educational initiatives, international collaboration and alternative routes to specialist registration. The College recognises that doctors may acquire the knowledge, skills and experience required for specialist practice through a variety of training environments and career pathways. However, regardless of the route by which a doctor develops their experience, competency assessment must always be robust, valid, transparent and capable of withstanding professional scrutiny.

RCEM’s expectations are not determined by where or how a doctor has trained, but by the quality, robustness and validity of the evidence used to demonstrate competence. These principles apply equally to all applicants seeking specialist registration through the Portfolio Pathway, irrespective of where they have gained their clinical experience. Maintaining these standards is essential to protecting patients, supporting assessors in fulfilling their professional responsibilities, and preserving public confidence in Emergency Medicine training and specialist registration.